0:00
/

Lectured by the Unbombed

Kyiv to Houston: What Americans Get Wrong About a Country at War

Egberto Willies and I came up through the same building. KPFT in Houston, Pacifica radio, the place where you learn that the money for the microphone comes from the people listening or it doesn’t come at all. We talked last night — his afternoon, my very late evening — and it ran a little over an hour, which is what happens when two independents who trust each other stop performing.

He opened on American politics and I want to hold his framing, because it’s the sharpest thing either of us said.

Everyone is talking about generational turnover in the Democratic Party. Willies’s point is that the turnover is not the story. Voters are not asking for a younger face. They’re asking for receipts. A young candidate who arrives as a fresh representation of the same oligarchy is not a change, and the electorate is beginning to price that correctly. He’s watched this from inside — flying around the country during the 2020 primary, campaigning in Latino neighborhoods and supermarkets in Nevada, then landing back in Houston and watching the field consolidate overnight after that win. He doesn’t think the progressive base has forgotten what that was.

His illustration is a Texas one, and it’s better than any national theory. Gene Green held District 29 in Houston for decades — a white congressman in a heavily Latino district, challenged repeatedly on exactly that basis, and he kept winning. Willies’s read: he knew the district. I can second it from the other end. I once left Gene a message about breaking up the Comcast monopoly and he called me back three days later, personally, told me his view, listened to me tell him he’d lost his nuts, and we both hung up thanking each other.

Willies calls this earned representation as against districted representation, and he’s clear that it’s not a mainstream position. Neither of us thinks racism has stopped being real. The argument is narrower: in a lot of districts the leadership has taken its own people for granted and stopped performing, and voters notice performance.

I gave him the version of that argument I have to live inside.

The story consuming Kyiv right now is the split between Mykhailo Fedorov and Zelensky. Almost all the foreign coverage I’ve seen renders it as a personality fight — he clashed with the president, he’s out, next. That’s a failure. What’s actually running underneath is a generational and institutional argument about how a country at war makes decisions: an inherited command culture that wants credit for seniority and time served, against a younger cohort saying we do not have time for that, we need investment now and iteration now and this structure is visibly not working.

You can hear it everywhere if you read Ukrainian rather than English. I read brigade pages. I read what soldiers write about mobilization, including the busification videos that look as ugly as they look. That ugliness is real and it is also a fragment. The larger pattern is people inside a system trying to hand their leadership better information and finding nobody is listening, and then routing around the system because survival mode makes you go find the thing that works. Some commanders have gone on record refusing orders and inviting the court-martial rather than get their people killed. Sometimes the change follows.

Then Fedorov announced investor backing from Palantir’s chief executive, and the reaction from abroad arrived within the hour. Deal with the devil. Naive. Traitor to your country. Most of it from people who had never heard his name before that day, who had been perfectly happy consuming four years of Ukrainian FPV footage without wondering who pushed the money and the industry into place behind it.

Here is what that class does not understand. Ukraine does not want to be a beggar nation. It does not want a defense capability that evaporates every time an American administration changes its mind. And the actual conversation happening in this country daily is an engineering one: their drone closes at seven hundred kilometers an hour, can we build something faster, theirs costs fifteen hundred, can we do it for a thousand. That is not procurement theater. That is a cost curve someone is going to die on.

I asked myself what the American equivalent would look like and it doesn’t exist, because the paradigm isn’t the same. You are not in an existential fight for the rest of your life. So the lectures I sat through yesterday about our traitorous defense minister came, without exception, from people who have never been bombed.

One landed while Egberto and I were talking. I turned the camera to the window.

We have had impacts within a kilometer of here on a regular basis. From the first of August until about five days ago we had essentially no air defense, and Russia responded exactly as you’d expect — salvo after salvo of missiles, almost no drones, all month. Then the Patriots were replenished and a French Crotale system arrived, and the drones came back, and now the attacks come in daylight. We’re on day seven of activity running nearly around the clock.

What that does to a life is specific. The metro stops. If you’re on the wrong side of the river when the alert sounds you don’t get home; you ride to the last station and get pushed out with hundreds of other people and you wait, fifteen minutes or three hours, nobody tells you which. The prepared food is gone from the shops by then. The produce shelves have been thinner since they started hitting the warehouses — Silpo, Fora, Fozzy, Rozetka, the post offices before that. Not military targets. The grocery distribution and the parcel network. They have been doing this for four years, and when the coverage flattens it into two sides trading smoke it erases the pattern entirely.

And you can still eat, because there are people on the street with fruit and vegetables, cash only, fresher than the store. Egberto pointed out that New York still has that and most of America doesn’t. He’s right. I grew up going to El Mercado del Sol in Houston. Those places are rare there now and ordinary here.

We spent the back half on how anyone is supposed to know any of this.

Willies brought up the Powell memorandum and the case that the information environment was engineered rather than drifted into. I brought the FCC ownership hearings I covered through the mid-2000s, flying to St. Louis and Atlanta to watch ordinary people testify that they no longer had local radio and no longer knew who owned their television station. That fight was lost quietly and we are living in the result.

Which is why I keep saying the coverage isn’t merely bad. It is compromised, complicit, or ignorant, and it is usually one of those three specifically rather than generally. What I want from this program going forward is closer to an epistemological exercise: not what is happening, but what are we learning wrong, and what about the way it reaches us made it wrong.

I have thirteen articles in the Kyiv Post and not one dollar has moved from them to me. That’s fine — I put them there because that information has to be in the country’s leading English-language paper. The studio is $380 a month. The travel to Dnipro and Mykolaiv and Sumy comes out of the same pocket. I have been covering POW and torture cases for four years, I’m one of very few people doing it in English, and I still cannot get traction on it. I would genuinely welcome competition from CNN and the BBC on that story. There isn’t any.

Egberto’s closing is the part I’d ask you to carry. After Obama won, people exhaled. They felt relief, went back to their lives, and the same interests walked straight back in. If the people who intend to do right by you win in November, that is the beginning of the work and not the end of it. And in the meantime: check your registration. In most states you’re locked out thirty days before the election, and Texas has no same-day option.

He signed off with one ask, which I’ll pass along exactly as he made it.

Don’t let democracy die.

Слава Україні. Героям слава.

Discussion about this video

User's avatar

Ready for more?